Red Dead Redemption

[Delta]

My all time favorite video game! Anyone agree?

[Deleted]

An overrated game, but it was still good. Undead Nightmare was really good.

[Delta]

Oh yeah, cant forget about that

[Grimgor Ironhide]

I actually greatly enjoyed it. In fact, until GTA 5 was released, it was my favorite Rockstar game. I never really connected with GTA 4. I played it, I enjoyed the open world, and the usual stuff, but I HATED Niko, and I just for the most part didnt enjoy the story until the DLCs were released (I like Johnny and Luis though). Then Red Dead comes along. Well, lets count the ways:

Its in Texas? +1
Wild West instead of a big city? +1
Old Guns to fit the setting? +1
Country living? +1
The chance to be a hero rather than being forced to be a villain? +1,000

So yes, I love it.

[Delta]

GTA V sounds awesome and my brother has it but he won't let me play it cause he's been paranoid since I accidentally destroyed my RDR disk.

[Lady]

I like Red Dead Redemption, but I Think i Prefer Undead Nightmare better.

[Destroyer]

I thought it was magnificent. There were parts in the story that I liked less and probably would have gone a different way with it, but overall, pretty good, and the gun fighting was super excellent. I was disappointed when I finished the story, and then... I didn't care to get all the outfits..

[Sebastian]

I own both Red Dead and Undead Nightmare. I prefer Undead Nightmare